Thanksgiving Dinner in Key West 2025: Best Restaurants, Menus & Reservations

Spending Thanksgiving in Key West means warm weather, island flavors, and a variety of places to enjoy a holiday meal. Most Thanksgiving dinners are concentrated in Old Town, the Historic Seaport, Casa Marina, and Stock Island, with options ranging from waterfront fine dining to casual local favorites and even a special Thanksgiving Sunset Dinner Sail. Many restaurants serve classic turkey plates, while others offer coastal-inspired dishes unique to the Keys. Reservations are strongly encouraged, and some locations sell out early—especially sunset dining and private-island experiences.

TL;DR: Thanksgiving in Key West 2025

• Key West offers warm weather, waterfront dining, and dozens of restaurants serving Thanksgiving dinner—from Old Town to Sunset Key, Casa Marina, and Stock Island.
• You’ll find everything from classic turkey plates to seafood-inspired holiday menus, plus unique experiences like the Thanksgiving Sunset Dinner Sail.
• Many restaurants sell out early, especially for sunset seatings and private-island dining, so reservations are strongly recommended.
• If you prefer eating at home or at your vacation rental, Key West offers plenty of Thanksgiving meals to go, local catering options, and fully prepared dinners.
• Beyond dining, Thanksgiving Day activities include boat rentals, sandbar charters, scooter & golf cart rentals, and even holiday cooking classes.

Our Key West Favorite Places for Thanksgiving

If you’re looking for the best places to eat in Key West on Thanksgiving, you’ll find everything from classic island traditions to unforgettable waterfront dining. Whether you want a cozy local spot, a holiday sunset sail with dinner and drinks, or an elevated brunch on a private island, Key West has some truly standout experiences for the holiday. Below are some of our favorite Thanksgiving places and experiences around the island—perfect for couples, families, and anyone wanting to enjoy the tropical side of the season.

Pepe’s Cafe: A Thanksgiving Tradition

Pepe’s Café in Old Town Key West serves a traditional Thanksgiving meal, continuing the decades-long tradition that makes it one of the island’s most iconic local restaurants. Known as the oldest restaurant in Key West, Pepe’s offers its classic comfort dishes, homemade breads, and rich daily specials, along with its famous Bloody Marys that help pass the wait. If you’re looking for a true Old Town Thanksgiving experience with authentic, long-standing Key West character, Pepe’s remains a favorite for both locals and visitors.

Old Town — 305-294-7192

Thanksgiving Sunset Dinner Sail: Dinner, Drinks & Live Music

The Thanksgiving Sunset Dinner Sail in Key West is a two-hour, family-friendly holiday cruise departing from the Historic Seaport on Thanksgiving Day aboard a spacious catamaran. Guests enjoy a festive buffet featuring turkey sliders with stuffing and cranberry sauce, honey ham sliders with artisan cheese, sweet potato tots, meatballs with gravy, holiday cheese and cracker trays, veggie and hummus trays, and a Thanksgiving dessert, along with an unlimited open well bar and live music.

Tickets are limited and advance reservations are required, as this special sunset sail traditionally sells out. Reserve Now or Learn More

Tempt Restaurant at The Saint Hotel: A relaxed yet elegant brunch

Celebrate Thanksgiving at The Saint Hotel in Key West with a four-course feast that blends classic flavors with the hotel’s signature “Saintly” twist. The menu includes a Cranberry Apple Quinoa Salad, Butternut Squash Soup, and a turkey-and-ham entrée with house-made dressing, gravy, mashed potatoes, candied yams, prosciutto-wrapped green beans, and cranberry sauce. Dessert options include a 5-layer chocolate mousse cake, pecan pie, or pumpkin pie. With its stylish atmosphere and prime location just off Duval Street, The Saint offers an intimate holiday dining experience ideal for couples or anyone looking to elevate their Thanksgiving meal. Adults only.

$55 per person | Reservations are required: 305-294-3200

Latitudes at Sunset Key: A Private Island Delight

Latitudes at Sunset Key offers one of the most exclusive holiday dining experiences in the Florida Keys, accessible by a short scenic ferry ride from the Key West Historic Seaport. Set on a private island with ocean views and upscale island décor, the restaurant is known for chef-driven seasonal menus featuring fresh, coastal-inspired dishes. Its intimate waterfront setting makes it a top choice for couples, families, and anyone seeking a memorable holiday dinner away from the crowds. Because Latitudes is one of the most in-demand dining destinations in Key West—especially for holidays and sunset seatings—advance reservations are required.

Sunset Key — 305-292-5394

Other Great Thanksgiving Places in Key West

If you’re looking for even more great places to enjoy Thanksgiving in Key West, you’re in luck—there are tons of local restaurants and resorts offering holiday specials all across the island. Whether you want a classic turkey dinner, a fresh seafood twist, a casual spot with no reservations, or a full buffet at one of Key West’s beachfront resorts, there’s something for every style and budget. From Old Town favorites to Stock Island gems, here are more of the best Thanksgiving dining options in Key West to help you plan the perfect holiday meal.

Banana Cafe

A Key West favorite! Serving a Thanksgiving menu from noon until they run out for just $27 per plate. Regular menu also available. No reservations needed
Old Town — 305-294-7227

Cafe Sole

New England style Thanksgiving dinner with marinated turkey and full traditional sides. Reservations highly recommended.
Old Town — 305-294-0230

Dante’s Key West

All you can eat buffet Noon–5pm with full Thanksgiving offerings. No reservations.
Old Town — 305-293-5123

The Docks

Turkey Dinner with all the fixings or regular menu. Reservations recommended but not necessary.
Stock Island — 305-396-7049

Duffy’s Steak and Lobster House

Always serving its regular menu along with traditional Thanksgiving Day specials on this holiday. Reservations are recommended.
Old Town — 305-296-4900

Flagler’s Restaurant at Casa Marina Resort

Casa Marina’s annual Thanksgiving Day buffet. Offering a full spread including the highly requested seafood raw bar! Enjoy a selection of cocktails, wines or beer. Reservations recommended.
Casa Marina — 305-293-6255

Four Marlins at The Reach Resort

Serving a traditional Thanksgiving Day dinner from 5-9pm. There will also be live music on the patio. Or, get it to go for $95.
Casa Marina — 305-293-6250

Frita’s Cuban Burger

Making special Thanksgiving empanadas, burritos, and more!
Old Town — 305-509-7075

Half Shell Raw Bar

Holiday Oyster Stew, Smoked Shrimp & Crab Toast, Citrus Shrimp & Avocado Salad, Fish & Fig Sammy, Baked Seafood Pasta, plus Fall drinks. Open 11AM–10PM.
Old Town — 305-294-7496

Hard Rock Cafe

Join us for a feast fit for a VIP! Walk-ins welcome and first come, first served.
Old Town — 305-293-0230

Hot Tin Roof at Ocean Key Resort

Enjoy a 4-course Thanksgiving Day menu for $130 per person. Reservations highly recommended.
Old Town — 305-295-7057

La Concha Key West

Thanksgiving dinner 5–10pm with multiple entrée options. $65 per person.
Old Town — 305-296-2991

La Creperie French Cafe Key West

Open 7:30AM–3PM with French-inspired breakfast and lunch. No reservations needed.
Old Town — 305-440-2240

La Grignote

Open for breakfast and lunch with an amazing turkey sandwich special.
Old Town — 305-916-5445

La Te Da

Offering a traditional turkey dinner every year on Thanksgiving from 2-8pm. Reservations highly recommended.
Old Town — 305-296-6706

Louie’s Backyard

Only open for dinner with specials. Reservations necessary.
Casa Marina — 305-294-1061

Mac’s Place

Starting at 11am, serving up a traditional Thanksgiving meal until it is gone for just $24 per person. Full menu also available.
The Meadows — 305-504-3648

Mangoes

Holiday specials include a Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner, Pan Seared Halibut and Seafood Paella. Reservations highly recommended.
Old Town — 305-294-8002

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen and Bar at The Perry

Enjoy a special prix fixe Thanksgiving menu from 12:30pm until 8pm. $75 adults / $37 kids.
Stock Island — 877-496-8712

Milagro Restaurant and Bar

A la carte holiday offerings from 3-9pm. Reservations recommended.
Old Town — 305-440-3534

Old Town Mexican Cafe

Enjoy a Thanksgiving special with a southwestern twist! Call for reservations!
Old Town — 305-296-7500

One Duval at Pier House

Regular menu or Thanksgiving Day special.
Old Town — 305-295-3255

Rams Head Southernmost

For $35 per person: roasted turkey, cornbread stuffing, mashed potatoes, candied yams, green bean casserole, gravy, rolls, and pumpkin pie.
Old Town — 305-440-3196

Richard Blais’ Four Flamingos at Hyatt Centric

$90 holiday menu including jerk brined turkey with the fixings.
Old Town — 305-809-4000

Southernmost Beach Cafe at Southernmost Beach Resort

Family style menu (includes wine) for $65 per person. Reservations recommended.
Old Town — 305-295-6550

Southernmost Moose Lodge

Free for members and their families! 5pm sharp. Dinner will include turkey and ham. Bring your favorite sides to share!
Stock Island — 305-294-3144

Yellowfin Bar and Kitchen at Ocean’s Edge Resort

Featuring a Thanksgiving Special: $35 per person or $55 per person family style (includes dessert). Available Noon–9pm.
Stock Island — 786-862-6321

Thanksgiving To Go in Key West

Catering and fully cooked Thanksgiving meals to go are a convenient option if you prefer not to dine out at a restaurant. This is especially popular for visitors staying in Key West vacation rentals who want to enjoy a holiday meal at home without the hassle of cooking. For a more budget-friendly choice, Publix offers affordable holiday meal packages, while many local Key West eateries provide high-quality prepared dinners. No matter which route you choose, you’ll find plenty of delicious Thanksgiving options across the island.

Eaton Good

Heat-and-serve Thanksgiving dinner for 8–12. Turkey, sides, ham, salads, pies available.
Old Town | 305-517-6058

Fausto’s Food Palace

Prepared turkey dinner $179.99 or turkey only $89.99.
Old Town | 305-296-5663 / 305-294-5221

The Green Pineapple

Vegan, gluten-free holiday desserts.
Old Town | 305-509-7378

Great Events

Dinner for 4 is $160. Add-ons available.
Old Town | 305-294-2252

Key West Cakes

Pumpkin pies $25, apple crumb $28, pecan pies $30.
Old Town | 305-296-4162

Key West Personal Chef

Multi-course holiday dinner for 10–15. Email to order: info@keywestpersonalchef.com
Stock Island | 305-714-0344

Old Town Bakery

Holiday breads.
Old Town | 305-396-7450

Moondog Cafe and Bakery

Cakes & pies. Order via email: bakery@moondogcafe.com
Old Town | 305-741-7699

Publix

Full turkey dinners, ham, mojo pork. Order ≥2 days ahead, online or in person.
Old Town | 305-296-2225 / 305-295-8045

Tavern N Town at Beachside Resort

Thanksgiving to-go: $425 includes full meal.
New Town | 305-296-8100

Non Traditional Thanksgiving Ideas

If you’re wondering what to do in Key West on Thanksgiving Day, you’ve got even more options than you might think. You can stretch out on the beach, take it slow at your hotel or vacation rental, or get out on the water for a real island-style adventure. Thanksgiving is also a great time to explore the island -rent a scooter or a golf cart and cruise around like a local, book a boat rental for the afternoon, or try a sandbar charter where you can relax in crystal-clear water. If you want something fun and tasty, you can even sign up for a cooking class and learn how to make some island favorites. Here are some of our top recommendations to help you enjoy Thanksgiving in Key West to the fullest.

Key West Sandbar Trips & Boat Rentals on Thanksgiving

Spend your vacation like a local, at the sandbar!

Explore the turquoise blue waters of Key West on your own boat rental. Stop at remote sandbars or just tour the island. There’s no better way to see Key West.

Be your own captain with a boat rental or let us do the driving and take one of our sandbar charters.

Thanksgiving Dinner: The Key West Cooking Show

November 27, 2025 – Gather your family and let us take care of the cooking! The Key West Cooking Show is serving a full Thanksgiving dinner all day on Thanksgiving Day. We’ll have four show times to choose from, where you can learn the secrets of slow-roasted turkey with classic fixings, island-inspired sides, and plenty of pie. Relax in our festive dining room, toast the holiday with cocktails, wine, and zero stress, and make Thanksgiving effortless this year. Reservations are required. Come hungry, leave happy, and let the Key West Cooking Show be your holiday tradition.

Buy Tickets – Two Seatings: 11:00 AM & 3:00 PM

Scooter & Golf Cart in Key West – Explore the Island with Ease

With perfect November weather, scooters are the easiest and most fun way to explore Key West on your own time.

Cruise around Key West, island-style, with eco-friendly electric golf carts, Scooter Rentals, or gas-powered Golf Cart rentals. Embark on an exhilarating journey with our roadworthy rentals, meticulously crafted to effortlessly transport you from one dream destination to the next. These vehicles promise a smooth and secure ride, elevating your vacation experience to new heights.

Reserve early – November is prime season for scooter rentals in Key West. Call or text us today to secure your ride.

Insider Tips for Thanksgiving in Key West

• Reserve early—really early. Popular places like Latitudes, Tempt, and sunset dinner cruises often sell out weeks in advance, especially for sunset or waterfront seating.
• Plan transportation ahead. Thanksgiving week gets busy in Old Town—scooter rentals and golf carts are the easiest way to get around, and they book up fast.
• Beach in the morning, dinner in the evening. Thanksgiving Day usually brings warm, sunny weather, making it perfect for a morning beach trip, sandbar charter, or boat rental before you sit down for dinner.
• Check menus before choosing. Key West restaurants vary widely—some serve classic turkey dinners, others offer seafood-forward menus or special prix-fixe holiday meals.
• Consider Thanksgiving to-go. If you’re staying in a vacation rental, a fully cooked meal from a local bakery or market can be easier, cheaper, and just as delicious as dining out.

Frequently Asked Questions: Thanksgiving in Key West 2025