Which Boat Should You Rent in Key West? Deck vs. Pontoon vs. Center Console
Choosing the right boat rental in Key West can make or break your day on the water. Whether you’re cruising to a remote sandbar, snorkeling the reef, or hosting a family outing, the type of boat you choose matters.
In this guide, we’ll compare deck boats, center console boats, and pontoon rentals – helping you pick the perfect fit for your Key West boating adventure.
Let’s break it down.
Deck Boats: Space + Speed for Social Cruising
Deck boat rentals are the ultimate blend of space and performance. With a wide, open layout and extended bow seating, these boats are ideal for larger groups who want to relax, cruise, and enjoy the water in comfort.
Best for:
- Families and friend groups up to 10
- Sandbar hangouts
- Cruising the coastline in style
Pros:
- Wide, stable platform with plenty of seating
- Easy to board and move around
- More horsepower than a pontoon (faster cruising)
Consider Deck Boats if: You want to spread out, enjoy the sunshine, and make stops for swimming or snorkeling without sacrificing comfort or performance.
Center Console Boats: Adventure-Ready and Versatile
If you’re planning to fish, snorkel, or explore with a little more edge, center console rentals are built for it. These boats offer 360° access around the hull, making them perfect for casting lines or jumping in the water.
Best for:
- Fishing trips
- Snorkeling excursions
- Adventurous couples or small groups
Pros:
- Full walkaround deck for active use
- More powerful and maneuverable
- Great for choppy conditions
Consider Center Console if: You’re into hands-on adventure, want to fish the flats, or just prefer a more agile ride.
Pontoon Boats: Laid-Back, Spacious, and Family-Friendly
Pontoon boat rentals are all about comfort, relaxation, and fun. Their wide, flat design makes them incredibly stable – great for families with kids or groups that want a no-stress day on the water.
Best for:
- Families with kids or older passengers
- Group outings, birthdays, and sandbar days
Pros:
- Extremely stable and easy to operate
- Tons of space for coolers, gear, and lounging
- Most beginner-friendly option
Consider Pontoon Boats if: You want a smooth, easy ride with plenty of room and no pressure to rush.
Which One Should You Choose?
Here’s a quick comparison of our boat rental types:
| Feature | 🛥️ Deck Boat | 🎣 Center Console | 🛳️ Pontoon Boat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Groups, cruising | Fishing, exploring | Families, lounging |
| Ride style | Fast & stable | Agile & sporty | Smooth & slow |
| Skill level required | Easy | Moderate | Very easy |
| Seating layout | Open bow | Walkaround | Large flat deck |
Need Help Choosing the Right Boat Rental in Key West?
Since 2007, Key West Boat Rentals has helped visitors explore Key West by boat – from sandbar trips and reef snorkeling to fishing adventures and family cruises. Whether you’re booking a pontoon rental for a group, a deck boat for sightseeing, or want a center console for sport fishing, we’ll help you find the perfect fit. Call or text today to reserve your boat rental in Key West.
Prefer to relax while someone else takes the helm? Ask us about our private sandbar charters with a licensed captain. It’s the easiest way to kick back, sip a drink, and enjoy the beauty of Key West without lifting a finger.
Contact us and we’ll point you in the right direction
Boat Rentals FAQs
Yes! Rentals and charters include coolers. You’re free to bring your own (including alcohol), just skip the glass containers. Remember, boat drivers must stay sober – drinking and boating don’t mix
We’ll let you know what’s included with your specific trip.
Key West Pontoon boats are popular for sandbar trips – spacious, shaded, and great for groups. Deck boats are a close second if you want a bit more speed, with space. For fishing or speed, a center console rental might be a better fit. Check out our boat rental guide to compare options and find the best fit for your plans.
Want a captain? Our sandbar charters let you relax while we handle the details.
You must have prior experience operating an outboard motorboat to rent a boat in Key West. Key West waters can change quickly, so safety is key. If you’re new to boating or just want to relax, we recommend one of our private sandbar charters with a licensed captain. You’ll get the same amazing experience without the stress of driving.
We offer half-day (4-hour), full-day (8-hour), and multi-day rentals. Some boats can be rented overnight or weekly – check out our multi-day rentals page or contact us to confirm availability.
Fuel is not included. You’ll only be charged for the fuel you use, based on local fuel dock prices at the marina when you return. Most guests use less fuel than they expect, especially when cruising to nearby sandbars.
Prepare yourself for a successful adventure by properly packing for your Key West boat rental day. This guide is here to assist both experienced and beginners in packing efficiently to guarantee a memorable and safe day on the water.
Yes! We offer weekly and overnight boat rentals on select boats. Perfect for nearby anchorages, fishing trips, or sandbar-hopping vacations. Availability is limited – contact us to confirm.
We’ve created a detailed boat day packing guide, but here’s the short list:
Reef-safe sunscreen and sun-protective clothing
Towels and waterproof bags
Plenty of water and snacks (or a cooler with drinks!)
Snorkel gear if you plan to explore reefs or sandbars
To rent a boat in Key West, you must:
Be at least 25 years old
Have prior experience operating outboard boats
If born on or after Jan 1, 1988, present a valid Florida Boater Education Card or complete a certified safety test online.
Contact us with any questions.
Yes, you can request a licensed captain for your boat rental or choose one of our captained charters, which include sandbar trips, snorkeling adventures, and sunset cruises. See Key West Charters for options or contact us to arrange a captain.
We offer a full fleet of rental boats in Key West, including:
Deck Boats – great for speed, space, and social cruising
Center Console Boats – perfect for fishing, snorkeling, and adventure
Pontoon Boats – ideal for families, birthdays, and chill sandbar days
Mini speed boat tours and captained sandbar charters available
Please call 305-422-9811 for availability.
- Security deposit on a major credit card. Please bring credit card and photo id to check in.
- Must have previous outboard boating experience – No Refund given without adequate experience
- Guests are responsible for gas. The boat will be filled back up at the marina.
- Check with marina before leaving on areas you can explore, based on wind and weather
- Florida Boaters Safety: Florida Law requires everyone born after Jan 1, 1988 to take a boaters safety test to drive a boat. Each driver must present a passed boaters safety test prior to departure.
- We review wind, tides, and safe areas at check-in to help you plan the perfect day
We’re here to help! Call or text us at 305-422-9811, or visit our contact page and we’ll guide you through your best boat rental options in Key West, sandbar charters, and Key West watersports.
Count on us to match you with the right boat rental or charter – offering real local advice – so you can relax, explore, and make unforgettable memories on the water.
Local since 2007. Here’s how we help visitors explore like a local.
